Skip to main content

CPAP vs Inspire Therapy

An evidence-based comparison to help you make the right choice for your sleep apnea treatment

Ready for Better Sleep?

Schedule a consultation with Dr. Jain to discuss your treatment options.

Contact Us (214) 308-1525

The Bottom Line

CPAP is more effective (95% vs 79% AHI reduction) and less expensive upfront. Inspire offers better long-term compliance (80% vs 30-50%) and quality of life. The "right" choice depends on your specific situation, insurance, and priorities.

Quick Comparison Table

FeatureCPAPInspire Therapy
Effectiveness (AHI Reduction)95%+ reduction in apnea events79% reduction (STAR trial)
Long-Term Compliance Rate30-50% (most quit within 1 year)80% at 5 years
ComfortMask, hose, pressurized airNothing on your face, sleep naturally
Upfront Cost$800-$3,000 (device + mask + supplies)$30,000-$40,000 (surgery + device)
Insurance CoverageAlmost always coveredCovered after documented CPAP failure
Travel ConvenienceMust pack machine, mask, power supplyImplanted - nothing to pack
MaintenanceDaily cleaning, monthly filter changes, annual mask replacementNone (battery lasts 11+ years)
Time to ResultsImmediate (first night)2-3 months (surgery + healing + titration)
Side EffectsClaustrophobia, dry mouth, skin irritation, air leaksTemporary tongue weakness, swallowing discomfort (usually resolves)
Partner SatisfactionMachine noise, mask barrierSilent, no barriers
FDA ApprovalSince 1980s2014 (now 5th generation device)
Best ForFirst-line therapy, severe OSA, central sleep apneaCPAP-intolerant patients, active lifestyle, travelers

When CPAP Is the Better Choice

You're newly diagnosed

CPAP should always be tried first. It's the gold standard with 95%+ effectiveness, works immediately, and insurance requires documented CPAP failure before covering Inspire.

You have severe OSA (AHI > 65)

Inspire only works for moderate-to-severe OSA (AHI 15-65). If your AHI is over 65, CPAP may be your only option unless your AHI can be reduced through weight loss or positional therapy.

You have central sleep apnea

Inspire only treats obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). If you have central sleep apnea (CSA) or mixed apnea, CPAP or ASV (adaptive servo-ventilation) is required.

Cost is a primary concern

Even with insurance covering both, CPAP has much lower out-of-pocket costs ($0-$500) vs Inspire surgery copays ($2,000-$5,000 typical).

You need immediate results

CPAP works the first night. Inspire requires surgery, 2-4 weeks healing, device activation, and 2-3 months of titration to optimize settings.

You're claustrophobic but haven't tried all masks

Modern CPAP masks include nasal pillows, nasal masks, and full-face options. Many "claustrophobic" patients succeed with minimal-contact nasal pillows. Try at least 3 different mask styles before giving up on CPAP.

When Inspire Is the Better Choice

You tried CPAP for 3+ months and can't tolerate it

This is the #1 reason patients choose Inspire. If you've genuinely tried CPAP with multiple masks, proper pressure adjustments, and it's still intolerable, Inspire offers 80% long-term compliance.

You travel frequently

Pilots, business travelers, and frequent vacationers love Inspire. No packing CPAP equipment, no worrying about power outlets or airline regulations. Just pack your remote control (size of car key fob).

Your relationship is suffering

CPAP masks create a physical barrier to intimacy and some partners complain about machine noise. Inspire is silent and invisible - many patients report improved relationship quality.

You're active/athletic

Athletes and active individuals find CPAP disruptive to their lifestyle. Inspire doesn't interfere with exercise, camping, or outdoor activities. Sleep in any position, move freely.

You have moderate OSA (AHI 15-65)

Inspire works best for AHI between 15-65. If you're in this range and meet other criteria (BMI under 32-35, no complete concentric collapse), you're an excellent candidate.

You want a permanent solution

Inspire battery lasts 11+ years with zero daily maintenance. No supplies to reorder, no equipment to replace. Long-term cost-effectiveness often favors Inspire over CPAP supplies ($300-500/year).

The Real Question: Will You Actually Use It?

Here's the truth most doctors won't tell you: CPAP is more effective IF you use it every night. But 50-70% of patients quit within the first year.

Inspire has 79% effectiveness but 80% of patients still use it 5 years later. A therapy you'll actually use long-term beats a "better" therapy you'll quit.

This is why the decision isn't just about effectiveness numbers - it's about adherence.

Research shows that CPAP used 4 hours/night is less effective than Inspire used 7+ hours/night. Insurance requires 4+ hours of CPAP use per night, but many patients barely hit that minimum and feel exhausted trying to tolerate the mask.

What About Insurance?

CPAP: Almost always covered as first-line therapy. Typical cost-sharing: $0-$500 out-of-pocket for equipment.

Inspire: Covered by Medicare and most major commercial insurers (Blue Cross Blue Shield, Aetna, Cigna, United Healthcare) BUT you must document CPAP failure first. This typically means:

  • 3-6 months of attempted CPAP use
  • Documented intolerance despite mask adjustments
  • Letter from sleep physician supporting Inspire candidacy

We coordinate all documentation for the surgeon's office, who handles Inspire prior authorization. Inspire approval rate is over 85% when patients meet medical criteria and have documented CPAP failure.

Can You Use Both?

Technically yes, though it's rare. Some patients use:

  • Inspire at home, CPAP when traveling - Paradoxically, some patients who couldn't tolerate CPAP nightly find they can handle it a few nights per month
  • CPAP for very severe nights - If Inspire reduces AHI from 40 to 8, but you get a cold and it spikes to 25, temporary CPAP use can help

What If Neither Works?

If CPAP fails and you don't qualify for Inspire (wrong AHI range, complete concentric collapse on sleep endoscopy, BMI too high), there are other options:

  • Genio (Nyxoah) - Newer hypoglossal nerve stimulator with different anatomy requirements. Some patients who don't qualify for Inspire qualify for Genio.
  • Oral appliances - Custom dental devices that reposition the jaw, effective for mild-to-moderate OSA
  • Weight loss - 10% weight reduction can reduce AHI by 30-50% in overweight patients
  • Positional therapy - If your OSA is primarily supine (back-sleeping), devices that prevent back-sleeping can help
  • Surgical options - UPPP, MMA, nasal surgery (lower success rates, more invasive)

Dr. Jain's Approach: Shared Decision-Making

As a Stanford-trained sleep physician and Inspire Care Team of Excellence physician, I believe in presenting all options with honest pros/cons and letting you decide based on your lifestyle, priorities, and values.

Some patients prioritize effectiveness above all else (CPAP). Others prioritize quality of life and adherence (Inspire). Both are valid choices. My job is to ensure you qualify medically for your preferred option and optimize your results.

Ready to Discuss Your Options?

Schedule a consultation to determine if you're a candidate for Inspire therapy or if optimizing CPAP therapy is the better path.

Schedule Consultation(214) 308-1525

Common Questions about CPAP vs Inspire